Small Business Insurance: What Each Policy Actually Costs in 2026

Most business owners buying insurance for the first time get quoted a single number and have no way to judge whether it’s reasonable. The number is almost meaningless without knowing which policies are inside it. Two quotes that look $200 apart often cover completely different things — and the cheaper one is sometimes the one that leaves you exposed.

What each policy type actually costs

Averages across small businesses, per Insureon’s 2026 data:

PolicyAverage monthlyWhat it covers
General liability$45Third-party injury, property damage, advertising injury
Workers’ compensation$54Employee injury and lost wages
Business owner’s policy (BOP)$83General liability + commercial property, bundled
Professional liability (E&O)$88Claims of negligent work or bad advice
Commercial property$108Your building, equipment, inventory
Cyber liability$129Data breach response, notification, recovery

General liability runs about $538 a year; a BOP around $990. The BOP is usually the better buy for anyone with premises or equipment — bundling liability and property costs less than purchasing them separately.

The carriers, by what they’re genuinely good at

The Hartford (AM Best A+) is the broadest option, covering sole proprietors through larger firms, with general liability from around $54 a month and a strong claims reputation. Some specialty coverages still require an agent rather than an online quote.

Hiscox (A) is built for independent contractors and freelancers, with general liability from roughly $25 a month and professional liability as its standout line. Minimum premiums are low, but there are fewer package options for larger businesses.

biBERK (A++ parent rating) is the budget play — Berkshire Hathaway-backed, sold direct with no broker, general liability from about $32 a month. You trade customisation for price.

Chubb (A++) suits growing businesses, with BOPs from around $75 a month, deeper underwriting and broader limits. Premiums run higher, and the property coverage is what you’re paying for.

Next Insurance (A+) is the fully-online option, with trade-specific pricing, guided coverage recommendations and certificates accessible from your phone — useful if clients constantly ask for proof of insurance. Less suited to complex businesses.

Progressive Commercial (A+) is the commercial auto specialist, from roughly $179 a month, with usage-based options and flexible payment plans for single vehicles or fleets.

What actually moves your premium

Industry classification does more work than anything else — a roofing contractor and a bookkeeper with identical revenue pay very different general liability rates. After that: payroll size, which drives workers’ comp; claims history; your coverage limits and deductible; and state, since workers’ comp rates are set at state level.

Quotes vary substantially between carriers for the same business, which is the single best argument for getting three rather than one.

Before you buy

Ask whether a BOP covers what you’d otherwise buy separately. Check whether professional liability is included or sold on top — service businesses almost always need it and frequently discover this after a claim. Confirm the AM Best rating of whoever is actually underwriting the policy, not just the brand selling it. And read what’s excluded, because that’s where quotes genuinely differ.

This article is general information, not insurance advice. Costs vary by trade, location and risk profile — get quotes for your own business.

Scroll to Top